Monday, June 6, 2011

Graphitization on Piping Materials

Everything about Piping Systems will be explain in this blog, and Piping & Fabrication will continue now with Graphitization. Graphitization is a time- and temperature-dependent nucleation and growth process, in which iron carbide in the form of pearlite first spheroidizes, and later forms graphite nodules. There are two general types:
1. Formation of randomly, relatively uniformly distributed graphite nodules in the steel. This reduces the room temperature mechanical strength somewhat, but does not affect the creep-rupture strength at elevated temperature.
2. A concentrated formation of graphite most frequently along the edges of the heat-affected zone of weldments. This is referred to as chain graphite, since a plane of nodules exists paralleling the weld bead contours.

The formation of these nodules, when aligned through the wall of a pressure part, creates planes of weakness, subject to rupture. Fracture characteristically occurs without prior warning. The first graphitization failure of a low-carbon steam piping material occurred in the early 1940s. The failure occurred after five and a half years of service in a steam line made of aluminum-killed carbon-molydenum steel. The fracture surface was located approximately 1⁄₁₆ in (1.6 mm) from the fusion zone of a butt weld.

The failure precipitated numerous and extensive research programs to understand the key variables of the mechanism and to determine the steels which would resist graphitization. Research has helped in the understanding of the problem, and led to restrictions adopted by the various design codes on use of materials subject to graphitization. Carbon steel and carbon-molybdenum grades are the most susceptible to this degradation process, with the latter being more so. Relative susceptibility of these two grades is also dependent on the steel’s aluminum content; the more aluminum, the greater the susceptibility. Additions of chromium in amounts as low as 0.5 weight percent make the steel essentially immune to graphitization.

The ASME Code permits the use of carbon and carbon-molybdenum steels in ASME Section 1 boiler applications up to 1000_F (538_C). A cautionary note is provided in the allowable stress tables of Section I indicating the carbon steels and carbon-molybdenum steels may be susceptible to graphitization at temperatures above about 800 and 875_F (427 to 468_C), respectively. ASME B31.1 has a similar precautionary note specifying limits of 775 and 850_F (413 and 454_C), respectively.

Graphitization is a mechanism dependent on diffusion and is not associated with a precise temperature of initiation (it occurs sooner at higher temperatures). Thus, the differences between the design codes only reflect different levels of conservatism in dealing with the failure mode. Many manufacturers extend even more severe restrictions, some prohibiting the use of these steels in piping applications outside the boiler or pressure vessel where rupture creates a serious safety hazard. Substitution of chromium-containing steel grades, such as SA.335 P2(1/2 Cr-1/2Mo), P11 (1 1/4 Cr-1/2Mo), and P22 (2 ¼ Cr-1Mo), is normally recommended for these applications. Grade P91 (9Cr-1Mo-V) is increasingly being used in high-temperature applications where use of P11 and P22 is not desirable due to their reduced mechanical strength.

No comments:

Post a Comment